Resolutions, opinions and reports search tool

It resolves to dismiss the request of the holder because restricting access to the health data of the holder, to all administrative, IT and citizen management staff of the Health Department, who may need access to it in the performance of their duties, would seriously distort the functioning and organisation of the health system. Furthermore, to the extent that the claimant also intended that the Ministry should enforce its right of opposition "in a global way and not individually", in relation to data relating to his or her health, which is treated at all Hospitals of Catalonia and Primary Care Centers, it is decided to also dismiss this claim, insofar as the Ministry of Health is not responsible for all the treatments pointed out by the claimant.

The complainant complains that the City Council has not replied either to the right of access, or to the right of rectification in relation to the waste collection service 'door to door'. With regard to the right of access, although the claimant requested access to public information, in reality, he referred to access to his personal data; and with regard to the right of rectification, although it was initially inferred that the City Council would have complied with the right exercised by the claimant, in reality the City Council did not rectify the data relating to the claimant's postal address. The petition formulated by the claimant in relation to both rights is appreciated.

La persona reclamante se quejaba por la desatención de tres solicitudes de ejercicio del derecho de acceso que presentó en 2016 y 2017 ante el COAC. Se declara que el COAC ha desatendido el derecho de acceso ejercido por la persona reclamante dado que solo ha acreditado haber dado respuesta a la primera de las tres solicitudes, siendo esta respuesta extemporánea. El derecho de acceso objete de la presente resolución se ejerció cuando estaba en vigor la antigua Ley Orgánica 15/1999, de 13 de diciembre, (LOPD) y el Real Decreto 1720/2007, de 21 de diciembre, (RLOPD), siendo estas las normas aplicables en el análisis de la eventual desatención del derecho de acceso ejercido por la persona reclamante.

La persona reclamante se quejaba que el centro médico no había atendido su pretensión de añadir a las anotaciones efectuadas a su HC por la psicóloga que lo había tratado, determinados párrafos redactados por ella misma. La persona interesada tendrá derecho a que se completen sus datos, siempre y cuando esta adición se adecue a las finalidades del tratamiento. En este caso, se desestima la reclamación en la medida que no hay ningún elemento que permita cuestionar el criterio médico-profesional de no completar la historia clínica de la persona reclamante en los términos solicitados por esta.

It is appropriate to dismiss the claim when the complainant considers the request for deletion consisting of withdrawing or anonymising images of a minor and is credited with having carried out the appropriate actions to make the law effective. The removal of the physical bulletins already delivered where the child's image appeared is disproportionate.

The claimant has the right to access electronic communications containing personal data, unless personal circumstances or reasons that might justify refusing access or that contain statements, opinions or explanations made by the various interviewed persons referring to his or her employment situation, or his or her mood, psychological or physical. It is appropriate to refuse access to undocumented information or information on which no indication of its existence is provided.

The resolution of the Directorate-General of Police which estimates the request for the deletion of personal data contained in the complainant's SIP PF file, without going into other considerations with regard to the substance, is extemporaneous, since the DGP has decided to delete its data.

Se declara extemporánea la resolución de la Dirección General de la Policía que estima la solicitud de supresión de los datos personales contenidos al fichero SIP PF de la persona reclamante, sin entrar en otras consideraciones respeto el fondo, puesto que la DGP ha resuelto suprimir sus datos.

La persona reclamante se quejaba por la desatención de una solicitud de ejercicio del derecho de acceso que presentó ante el Ayuntamiento, sin que este último le diera ninguna respuesta. Al respeto, se declara que el Ayuntamiento ha atendido de forma extemporánea la solicitud de acceso de la persona reclamante, sin entrar en otras consideraciones respecto al fondo, puesto que, en el marco del presente procedimiento de tutela de derechos, el Ayuntamiento ha librado la documentación a la persona reclamante.

It is considered unlikely that the City Council does not have the requested recording, although the right of access to the recording is recognised, unless the City Council does not have a copy and is not within its reach.