In principle, the direct telephone number of a City Council Department is not personal data, unless it is directly linked to a single person. In any case, if there is no specific number attributed to the Department, it cannot be subject to the right of access. The right of access to public information does not justify the disclosure of the e-mail address attributed personally to an employee for work reasons, taking into account that citizens already have another generic address established by the City Council for get in touch with them.