The law of the town councilors, once those that are part of the opposition have been included, of accessing the information necessary for the exercise of its functions can include the access to a relation of the staff of the Town Council with indication of the name, charge and dirty remunerations perceived, without harm of its duty of reservation. The general publication of the identification of all the employees of the Town Council in a joint way with the place that they occupy and the remunerations perceived by each of them is not adapted to the regulations of data of personal character protection.